National Service as Paid Volunteering? Uh…No.

If you’ve been considering a term of national service, keep in mind some of the biggest differences between doing a year-long term of full-time service and serving as a community volunteer.

To the uninitiated, a term of national service can seem to be “paid volunteering” because participants earn a basic living allowance. However, real differences exist, and local communities throughout the United States feel the direct impact of those differences.

Community Volunteers

From Flickr user who.log.why

From Flickr user who.log.why

Community volunteers donate their time through a nonprofit or school. They improve their communities because they can extend the human resource capacity of the places where they volunteer.

The amount of time they donate is up to them, but it’s usually part time. Some volunteers join a service project for a few hours on a single day, achieve greatness, feel good, and move on.

An organization’s part-time, longer term community volunteers may help out on sustained projects, or they may tackle shorter tasks that change from day to day.

Finally, as long as their duties are within the bounds of labor laws, the specific assignments are between community volunteers and their supervisors. Community volunteer service rarely comes under strict scrutiny for effectiveness, sustainability, and performance measures the way national service corps member positions do.

In sum, in the United States millions of community volunteers collectively devote billions of hours of their time to causes they believe in. Their contributions to social services are crucial to the operation of most nonprofit organizations and schools. Most serve on a part-time basis, often while in school, gainfully employed, or retired.

National Service Corps Members

picture-10Full-time national service is different in that participants — often called members or corps members — really dedicate all their work-day time to their service. In fact in at least two programs, members cannot hold down any work outside of their service.

National service programs in the United States include AmeriCorps, AmeriCorps*VISTA, AmeriCorps*NCCC, Teach For America, City Year, and many, many others (see the list of Corps and Coalitions in the right-hand side bar of this blog) not all of which receive funds from the Corporation for National and Community Service (CNCS).

CNCS funds—in part—most of these domestic service corps. It invests money through states, national organizations, and local communities, and that funding is leveraged through host service site matching contributions and other private donations.

Each service program is evaluated and approved at the state or federal government level before funding comes through and corps member recruitment begins. Grant proposals requesting funding for members must show performance outcomes, goals, and measurements. Corps members and their supervisors track the effectiveness of their service regularly, and supervisors write grant reports detailing corps member achievements.

Corps members initiate and lead hefty projects, on critical issues, like disaster preparedness and response, education, poverty, environment, and public safety.

Because corps members serve for a period of 10 to 12 months (or longer, if they commit to a second term) they have a chance to affect lasting, positive change in their organizations — through developing new programs, identifying and going after new sources of funding, and leveraging the efforts of millions of community volunteers.

Corps members also change their communities in permanent ways — by serving in schools, tutoring struggling kids throughout their term, consistently mentoring children of incarcerated parents, increasing the job skills of recent immigrants or high school dropouts, rebuilding communities in the wake of natural disasters, and creating access to affordable health care through local clinics and health organizations and more.

Finally national service is an investment in the corps members themselves, developing the future of public service leadership in the United States. National service corps members receive hours of targeted technical skill-building training throughout their terms. Two-thirds of AmeriCorps members followed in a longitudinal study go on to public service careers. The Eli Segal AmeriCorps Education Award has made further education possible for thousands of alumni.

The achievements of community volunteers are many and great.  The service of AmeriCorps members is closer to the equivalent of the federal government offering human resource grants to local communities to contribute in crucial capacities. It’s not paid volunteering.

Check out Tim’s post on Change/Wire, which also features video testimonials of service corps participants talk about their achievements.

add to :: Add to Blinkslist :: add to furl :: Digg it :: add to ma.gnolia :: Stumble It! :: add to simpy :: seed the vine :: :: :: TailRank :: post to facebook

6 thoughts on “National Service as Paid Volunteering? Uh…No.

  1. Pingback: National Service and “Paid Volunteers” | Change / Wire

  2. Wow, this is really insightful. Thanks for sharing it. I’m sure my family’s volunteer service efforts in our community pale in comparison to the work a full-time volunteer through any number of corps can provide. Remember the WPA? The CCC? Still, we strive to do a good deed, volunteer our time or otherwise help make our community a better place to be.

  3. Thanks for reading the blog. I think your comment perfectly illustrates why comparing the two forms of service is inadequate (although I was kind of doing that in the blog post — or at least responding to the comparison that’s often made). — Volunteering is crucial for communities and civic engagement, and I love it that you volunteer with your family. That’s how I learned to serve too, and I hope my son will learn in the same way. Full-time national service is simply a different kind of undertaking.

  4. Hi Amie,

    I believe it is a mistake to use the term “paid volunteer.” Volunteer in this case only means you are accepting the work of your own free will because these “volunteers” are compensated for their time. That can be said of any job a person accepts.

    I support National service programs and believe they are critical. You have done a great job of describing the impact those in national service positions can have. Both the national service members and volunteers can make an impact.

  5. Hi Roger! You make excellent points — “volunteering” is a way anyone can step up to do their part, whether it’s taking on an extra project at work, or raising your hand to answer a question in class, or leading a movement.

  6. I want to let everyone know how grateful I am for the oportunity to serve in the AmeriCorp Program. I have learned so much I would normally not have been exposed to. Thank you again for this opportunity to work with the Daviess County Emergency Management Agency. I am making so many new friends that I can’t tell you haw wonderful it is. I will forever be a volunteer. Thanks Again, Joetta O’Brien

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s